Month: February 2009

  • Oscar Post-Mortems

    Well, another Oscar season has come and gone, and I’m certainly glad that I saw Slumdog Millionaire when I did, cuz it’s been a long time since I’ve actually seen a Best Picture winner (I think Return of the King was the last one, and that was five years ago). One interesting sidenote is that I believe that Slumdog Millionaire is the only one of the five nominated films that ends on a high note (correct me if I’m wrong, but I believe the other four all have downer endings). At any rate, critics are gonna complain that the ceremony was boring, as they always do, but we’ve been down that road before, and it’s really no use rehashing my old complaints about their complaints.

     

    As far as Oscar Picks go, although we both improved on our scores from last year, my mom still edged me 11 to 9. For some reason, I was hesitant to choose The Dark Knight for ANY category, and it came back to bite me. At any rate, I got Picture, Actress, Animated Feature, Cinematography, Costume Design, Film Editing, Makeup, Original Song, and Adapted Screenplay. My mom got Picture, Supporting Actor, Animated Feature, Art Direction, Directing, Film Editing, Live Action Short Film, Sound Editing, Sound Mixing, Visual Effects, and Original Screenplay.

     

    In terms of hosting, Hugh Jackman was certainly a change of pace from all the comedians they’ve been using recently. He wasn’t the greatest, but he wasn’t the worst either. The musical numbers fell kind of flat, even though he is a pretty good singer. I did like the tongue-in-cheek complaints that the Academy won’t recognize comic book movies, which became less tongue-in-cheek when he proclaimed himself Wolverine (which I, in turn, had to explain to my parents).

     

    Other observations:

     

    ·         The idea of presenting most of the awards in the same order they would occur in the production process was kind of neat. It looked like they had the Phantom of the Opera’s chandelier stored in the background, though.

    ·         Steve Martin is still not funny.

    ·         Upon further thought, it was probably only a matter of time before the Oscars featured a Bollywood dance number. “Jai Ho” was a good, catchy tune, though. One thing I don’t get is that there are a few lines of the song that are in Spanish. And why were the dancers accompanied by Japanese taiko drummers?

    ·         A lot of the “comedic” pairups just didn’t work. I already mentioned that Steve Martin is not funny. Neither is Ben Stiller, although I realize that he was trying to imitate Joaquin Phoenix (even though I never saw the Letterman interview). The funniest presenter was probably Will Smith (“Hugh must be backstage taking a nap or something”). Jack Black is normally funny, but his routine with Jennifer Aniston totally bombed. The Pineapple Express bit would also not have worked, but having Janusz Kaminski was so randomly bizarre that it was funny.

    ·         Another thing that I’m unsure of was what they did with the acting awards. Breaking with tradition, they had five former winners in each category laud the nominees one-by-one and then announced the winner. Not only did that deprive me of seeing the actors in clips from their respective films, it seemed to me like it took a lot more time.

    ·         Where were Javier Bardem and Daniel Day-Lewis?

    ·         It was a really good night for India and Japan.

    ·         The memorial tribute with Queen Latifah singing would’ve been okay if the cameraman would stop the continuous panning. I couldn’t read half the names.

    ·         There was a plea that I wanted to make that had absolutely nothing to do with movies or the Oscars, but I elected not to because it sounds really dirty out of context.

    ·         Usually, when someone wins a lifetime achievement Oscar or the Thalberg award or the Jean Hersholt Humanitarian Award, they give a really long speech. Not Jerry Lewis. His acceptance speech was shorter than a lot of the regular winners.

    ·         Something I find somewhat amusing is that for once, the critics don’t agree on what worked and what didn’t. For instance, MSN did not like Hugh Jackman’s opening number, but Yahoo loved it.

    ·         Now for fashion. Looked good: Kate Winslet, Anne Hathaway, Hugh Jackman, Halle Berry, Tina Fey.

    ·         Looked bad: Miley Cyrus, Sophia Loren, Jessica Biel, Tilda Swinton.

    ·         Caveats: Angelina Jolie would’ve looked good except the giant ring and earrings she was wearing looked like cheap plastic. Marisa Tomei’s dress looked like it was designed by M.C. Escher. Meryl Streep looked very matronly.

    ·         The lady who won for the Best Documentary Short must’ve been sitting WAY in the back. Also, while they were reading off the winner of another award (don’t remember which), Frank Langella was caught on camera trying to find his seat.

  • BEST PICTURE

     

    The Nominees Are:

    • The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
    • Frost/Nixon
    • Milk
    • The Reader
    • Slumdog Millionaire

     

    Erin’s Pick: Slumdog Millionaire

    My Mom’s Pick: Slumdog Millionaire

    The Winner Last Year Was: No Country for Old Men

     

    I just saw Slumdog Millionaire last night, so now I feel better picking it. It is a good movie, albeit one with some rather chaotic editing and it was a little hard to follow at times (I’d also recommend learning a little bit about Indian culture before watching it). On the other hand, right now the field is kinda wide open, or at least, moreso than it’s been in recent years.

  • BEST DIRECTOR

     

    The Nominees Are:

    • David Fincher (The Curious Case of Benjamin Button)
    • Ron Howard (Frost/Nixon)
    • Gus Van Sant (Milk)
    • Stephen Daldry (The Reader)
    • Danny Boyle (Slumdog Millionaire)

     

    Erin’s Pick: Ron Howard (Frost/Nixon)

    My Mom’s Pick: Danny Boyle (Slumdog Millionaire)

     

    The Winner Last Year Was: Joel & Ethan Cohen (No Country for Old Men)

     

    This is one of those rare years where the Best Director nominees correlate exactly with the Best Picture nominees. However, there aren’t very many usual suspects in the mix. Ron Howard’s pretty much the only one. The cinema purists hate Ron Howard, but I don’t. I like a lot of the movies he’s directed, so I’m going for him here.

  • BEST ACTOR

     

    The Nominees Are:

    • Richard Jenkins (The Visitor)
    • Frank Langella (Frost/Nixon)
    • Sean Penn (Milk)
    • Brad Pitt (The Curious Case of Benjamin Button)
    • Mickey Rourke (The Wrestler)

     

    Erin’s Pick: Frank Langella (Frost/Nixon)

    My Mom’s Pick: Frank Langella (Frost/Nixon)

     

    The Winner Last Year Was: Daniel Day-Lewis (There Will Be Blood)

     

    Frost/Nixon is the only movie here that I have an interest in seeing. Meanwhile, my mom just likes Frank Langella.

  • BEST ACTRESS

     

    The Nominees Are:

    • Anne Hathaway (Rachel Getting Married)
    • Angelina Jolie (Changeling)
    • Melissa Leo (Frozen River)
    • Meryl Streep (Doubt)
    • Kate Winslet (The Reader)

     

    Erin’s Pick: Kate Winslet (The Reader)

    My Mom’s Pick: Meryl Streep (Doubt)

     

    The Winner Last Year Was: Marion Cotilliard (La Vie En Rose)

     

    Kate Winslet’s been due for a while, so why not?

  • BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR

     

    The Nominees Are:

    • Josh Brolin (Milk)
    • Robert Downey Jr (Tropic Thunder)
    • Philip Seymour Hoffman (Doubt)
    • Heath Ledger (The Dark Knight)
    • Michael Shannon (Revolutionary Road)

     

    Erin’s Pick: Josh Brolin (Milk)

    My Mom’s Pick: Heath Ledger (The Dark Knight)

     

    The Winner Last Year Was: Javier Bardem (No Country For Old Men)

     

    I’m giving my mom a freebie point on this one cuz Heath Ledger’s name is probably already engraved on the freakin’ statue. Now, although my mom says The Dark Knight is too dark, she also says that Ledger DID give a good performance in it.

     

    BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS

     

    The Nominees Are:

    • Amy Adams (Doubt)
    • Penelope Cruz (Vicky Christina Barcelona)
    • Viola Davis (Doubt)
    • Taraji P. Henson (The Curious Case of Benjamin Button)
    • Marisa Tomei (The Wrestler)

     

    Erin’s Pick: Amy Adams (Doubt)

    My Mom’s Pick: Amy Adams (Doubt)

     

    The Winner Last Year Was: Tilda Swinton (Michael Clayton)

     

    Neither of us have seen any of these movies, but we both enjoyed Amy Adams in Enchanted. By the way, I don’t think I’d be going out on a limb if I said that Marisa’s choice would undoubtedly be Marisa Tomei.

  • BEST ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY

     

    The Nominees Are:

    • Frozen River
    • Happy-Go-Lucky
    • In Bruges
    • Milk
    • WALL-E

     

    Erin’s Pick: WALL-E

    My Mom’s Pick: Milk

     

    The Winner Last Year Was: Juno

     

    You know, Pixar movies always seem to get nominated in this category, but they never win. Is it that “cartoon” stigma (similar to the way it took 76 years for a fantasy movie to win Best Picture)? At any rate, there are quite a few critics who believe WALL-E should’ve been nominated for Best Picture, so maybe this is Pixar’s year. Then again, maybe not.

     

    BEST ANIMATED FEATURE

     

    The Nominees Are:

    • Bolt
    • Kung-Fu Panda
    • WALL-E

     

    Erin’s Pick: WALL-E

    My Mom’s Pick: WALL-E

     

    The Winner Last Year Was: Ratatouille

     

    Considering the very weak competition, if WALL-E doesn’t win, something’s screwy. It’s definitely one of Pixar’s best movies (which really is saying something), and very cute. They did a great job on it.

  • BEST ART DIRECTION

     

    The Nominees Are:

    • Changeling
    • The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
    • The Dark Knight
    • The Duchess
    • Revolutionary Road

     

    Erin’s Pick: The Duchess

    My Mom’s Pick: The Curious Case of Benjamin Button

     

    The Winner Last Year Was: Sweeney Todd

     

    I have not seen any of these movies, but period pieces do tend to do well, and The Duchess has the most potential for that (Otherwise, it sounds like a very depressing movie).

     

    BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY

     

    The Nominees Are:

    • The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
    • Doubt
    • Frost/Nixon
    • The Reader
    • Slumdog Millionaire

     

    Erin’s Pick: Slumdog Millionaire

    My Mom’s Pick: Doubt

     

    The Winner Last Year Was: No Country for Old Men

     

    I haven’t seen any of these movies, but Slumdog Millionaire is the one I have the most interest in seeing. I have a slight interest in Frost/Nixon as well. My mom chose Doubt because the play won a Tony Award and a Pulitzer Prize.

  • BEST COSTUME DESIGN

     

    The Nominees Are:

    • Australia
    • The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
    • The Duchess
    • Milk
    • Revolutionary Road

     

    Erin’s Pick: The Duchess

    My Mom’s Pick: Australia

     

    The Winner Last Year Was: Elizabeth: The Golden Age

     

    It’s all period pieces this time, to some extent. You’ve got World War II, the 1920s through whenever (haven’t seen the movie yet), the 1700s, the 1970s, and the 1950s. The other odd thing about this category is that it’s one of the few places where critically-panned movies can still win (as evidenced by the last two recipients). If this holds up, Australia would be the most likely one to prevail, even though I don’t think it got universally horrible reviews. As an aside, when was the last time Nicole Kidman was in something successful?

     

    BEST FOREIGN LANGUAGE FILM

     

    The Nominees Are:

    • The Baader Meinhof Complex (Germany)
    • The Class (France)
    • Departures (Japan)
    • Revanche (Austria)
    • Waltz with Bashir (Israel)

     

    Erin’s Pick: The Class

    My Mom’s Pick: The Class

     

    The Winner Last Year Was: The Counterfeiters (Austria)

     

    I would give you plot synopses here for all the movies, but a few of them are really complicated and would take forever to write about, so I’m not going to. At any rate, The Class is apparently about a teacher and his racially diverse group of students at a school in inner-city Paris. It seemed like the most interesting of the group.

  • BEST DOCUMENTARY FEATURE

     

    The Nominees Are:

    • The Betrayal (Nerakhoon)
    • Encounters at the End of the World
    • The Garden
    • Man on Wire
    • Trouble the Water

     

    Erin’s Pick: Encounters at the End of the World

    My Mom’s Pick: Trouble the Water

     

    The Winner Last Year Was: Taxi to the Dark Side

     

    Well, the nominees are nowhere near as political as last year’s lot, but the plotlines sure are different from one another. The Betrayal is the story of a Laotian family who is forced to flee the country during the Vietnam War. Encounters at the End of the World is a nature documentary about Antarctica. The Garden is the story of a 14-acre community garden in South Central Los Angeles that is threatened by land developers. Man on Wire chronicles a daredevil’s (illegal) tightrope walk across the twin towers of the World Trade Center in 1974. Trouble the Water is the story of a couple who survived the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina (apparently the film makes extensive use of footage from the couple’s video camera).

     

    BEST CINEMATOGRAPHY

     

    The Nominees Are:

    • Changeling
    • The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
    • The Dark Knight
    • The Reader
    • Slumdog Millionaire

     

    Erin’s Pick: Slumdog Millionaire

    My Mom’s Pick: The Dark Knight

     

    The Winner Last Year Was: There Will Be Blood

     

    I haven’t seen any of these, so I chose the one that I am the most interested in seeing. My mom chose The Dark Knight because it’s the only one that she has seen. By the way, I read some entertainment columnist who was mad that The Dark Knight, for the most part, was only nominated for “tech” awards (and Heath Ledger). His argument was that it was the most successful movie of 2008 and apparently #2 on the all-time box office list. Dude, in case you hadn’t noticed, the top movie at the box office in any given year usually does not get a lot of Oscar recognition. This page has a list of the top movie of every year since 1915. Most of them did not win or were even nominated for the “big” awards. In the past twenty years, only Forrest Gump, Titanic, and LOTR: The Return of the King were both box-office champs and Best Picture winners. As for his other argument, actually, Wikipedia has The Dark Knight ranked at #4 on the all-time list, not #2. Return of the King and Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest are both between The Dark Knight and Titanic (and of the top 10, ONLY Titanic and ROTK have won Best Picture, and The Two Towers is the only other one to have been nominated). But I digress.